Beef in Guinness stew


I was trawling through some of my old posts the other day and stumbled upon my Lancashire hotpot recipe, originally intended to be the first in a series of British dishes.  But, as you do, I got somewhat distracted and of course Part I was as far as we got.  At the time of writing, I had a pretty good idea if what the second dish should be – I just never got round to blogging it but when I made this dish again last Friday night in celebration of St Patrick’s Day, I decided that it was high time I wrote it up! Now as I’ve said before on this blog, I’m all for cooking with alcohol (and I don’t just mean a glass of wine while I’m stirring the soup!).  I think wine, beer, sherry, whisky etc etc can immeasurably to the depth of flavour of a dish and apparently, I’m not alone:  Sumerian and Egyptian doctors had already agreed in about 1,700BC that cooking with beer was good for the health (of course, this prompted generations of unscrupulous merchants to marinate food heavily in alcohol so as to disguise the fact that it was inferior, not what the customer was paying for, or just plain rancid!)  There seems to be some debate as to whether beer can or cannot tenderize meat – some argue that because alcohol denatures protein, it will tenderize meat merely by its presence in the marinade.  Others argue that beer will no more tenderize meat than lemonade will.  You decide.  All I know is that if you cook something long enough and slow enough in alcohol, a) it will be meltingly tender; b) it will have become infused with the flavour of the alcohol you cooked it in; and c) the alcohol will have boiled off, so you can safely eat your coq au vin and drive home legally 😉 I have been making a variation on this recipe for years – in fact, it is probably the first main course that I started cooking for friends.  Of course back then, on a student budget, the dish was a little less upmarket.  I remember standing in a supermarket clutching the entire meagre budget for a student dinner party and trying to gauge which pack of brisket contained the least bone by weight (gotta get more meat for your money!!).  Why brisket?  Well, because it was the cheapest and because that’s what my mom recommended – and we all know that moms know best in these matters 😉 As for the beer, imported Guinness was way out of our budget, so by brisket in beer recipe was usually stewed in th golden can of goodness that is Castle Lager, and apart from the meat it contained precious little other than salt and onions. One of the most memorable times that I made this was on a student holiday to my beloved Plettenberg Bay in about 1991.  Every year my brother and I would rent a (very very basic) holiday house for a week after our end-of-year exams in November.  Of course, there were always plenty of takers for the extra rooms, and on this occasion in particular I recall that one bedroom containing three single beds accommodated me, my boyfriend, my brother, his girlfriend, plus another couple – two to a bed.  Oh, and did I mention that two out of the six occupants snored so that the foundations rattled?!?  But we though this was actually pretty luxurious as there were people in the upstairs bedroom sleeping on the floor!!  And if memory serves, possibly also somebody on a mattress on the balcony…  Aaaaah, those halcyon days.  Such contentment with so little. Anyway, on this occasion my brother and his friends had moved in a few days before my arrival, and by the time I go there they had been subsisting on a diet of beer, take-away hamburgers, charred braai (BBQ) meat, beer, hot-dogs, toast and beer for a few days.  I had promised to make them a proper home-cooked meal when I arrived and my arrival (armed with a cooler-bag full of brisket) was greeted with much enthusiasm!!  The kitchen (unsurprisingly) was poky and sadly lacking in sharp knives, so much cursing and hacking the brisket off the bones ensued.  But there was an enormous pot and copious amounts of beer, so in it all went for 3 hours while we played a very competitive game of quarters and savoured the smells developing in the kitchen.  After 3 hours, the population in the house had swelled to capacity (clearly, word had got out that a cooked meal was imminent!!), the level of bonhomie had risen considerably (aaah, the enduring power of alcohol!), and the stew was ready.  It was’t glamorous, it wasn’t haute cuisine, but I still have a photo of the pre-dinner toast that we drunk and you would struggle to find so many beaming faces around any table.  As my brother took his first forkful of the stew, his smile grew even broader and he proposed a toast:  “To Jeanne – that’s my sister!”.  It was and still is one of my proudest culinary moments.  Ever. BEEF IN GUINNESS STEW 

1kg chuck steak in 4cm cubes

a little plain flour for coating

3Tbsp vegetable oil

1 large onion sliced

3-4 carrots, thinly sliced

2 celery sticks, thinly sliced

half a punnet of mushrooms, roughly chopped

2tsp sugar

1tsp English mustard powder

1 Tbsp tomato puree

1×3 inch strip of orange rind

600ml Guinness or other dark stout

bouquet garni

salt & pepper

Toss the beef cubes in flour to coat. I usually mix the flour with salt and pepper in a Ziploc bag and toss the cubes in there – works like charm and very little mess. Heat 2 Tbsp of oil in a large shallow pan and cook the meat in batches till lightly browned. Remove from the pan and keep warm. Add the remaining oil to the pan. Cook the onion till well-browned, stirring occasionally and adding the carrot and celery towards end. Stir in the sugar, mustard, tomato puree, orange rind, Guinness and seasoning. Add the bouquet garni and bring to the boil. Return meat and any juices to the pan. If necessary, add water to ensure that the meat is covered. Cover pan tighly and simmer gently for 2-2.5hrs until meat very tender. About half an hour from the end of the cooking time, add the chopped mushrooms. Serve on mashed potatoes. Notes As I mentioned above, I have made a variation on this recipe using brisket instead of chuck. From this handy diagram of beef cuts, I learned that they are similar cuts, with chuck coming from slightly higher up on the shoulder than brisket. (Chuck, brisket, round and shank are the toughest cuts because they come from the parts of the animal that work the hardest – the legs – and are all really only suitable for long, slow cooking.) So cubes of any of these cuts should be suitable for this stew. The mushrooms are optional, but I always find they add a nice element. I have on occasion not had citrus in the house and made the recipe without the strip of rind – this is definitely a mistake! The rind (and even some zest if you like) adds immeasurably to the flavour. I have also used clementine rind successfully, so any sweet citrus will do. I often find that once I have browned the meat in the pan, there is so much flour sticking to the bottom that using the same pan is simply an invitation for the stew to stick. I usually transfer the meat (and later the sauce) to my trusty Le Creuset Dutch oven and cook it slowly in a medium oven. I served my stew on garlic mash and, in honour of St Patrick’s Day, alongside brocolli with Irish cheddar and breadcrumbs for a crispy, tangy topping. And of course the only suitable beverage is a glass of Guinness… Sláinte!

If you enjoyed reading this, please consider sharing it using the social media buttons below the post. I'd also love to hear what you thought about this post so please do leave a comment below. Hope to see you again soon!

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. says

    I can’t help but think there is not much at all English about this recipe, delicious and scrumptious as it sounds.
    the guinness, the irish cheddar, the st paddy’s day celebrations…?

  2. says

    Hey – I’m a colonial!! We think of “the English” as anyone who came from the little collection of islands off the coast of France :o) (yes, says Sam, and next she’ll be calling the Canadians American!!)
    But, of course, you are right – hence the change of the title post to a more inclusive description!

  3. says

    jeanne…I made something for eotmeote this month! yay! first time in a long time i managed to get my act together! is there a theme?
    plus, I KNOW you’d never call a canadian an american….

  4. says

    Oh Jeanne, I love this dish and make it even when it’s warm… yours looks fabulous, maybe you can make some next time we meet up 😉 Great post, as always!

  5. Pete says

    Not much English, I’ll remind you that Cheddar is a cheese origniated from Cheddar, Somerset, England. Irish Cheddar is an Irish copy of the world famous English Cheese I’ll laso remind you that Guiness is owned and brewed in Ireland by an English company……….

  6. Sarah K says

    Well Pete, Guinness (two n’s) may be owned by an english company now but it certainly is not English, nor was it developed in England, the english even drink it differently from how it is meant to be enjoyed, aka room temperature, making it bitter cold only serves to dull the taste. Irish cheddar is NOT a copy of English, because it certainly tastes better and different, hence not a ‘copy’ but a variation, and Ireland is not British. Only some of it… My point is not to highlight Irish English rivalry, but to mention that Guinness beef stew is and always will be an Irish staple and an Irish Invention. There is no point saying otherwise… The recipe looks great though, I have never tried the rind and I will give it a go next time…